All curriculum reviews

    BookShark

    A faith-neutral, literature-based print curriculum that ships a year of real books plus a day-by-day Instructor's Guide, and puts the entire teaching and grading load on the…

    Parent teaches and marks
    Charlotte Mason
    Eclectic
    Traditional/School-at-Home
    Visit site
    As a full curriculum
    3.8/5
    As a supplement
    3.8/5
    How this is scored

    How it scored

    Nine dimensions, each scored 0 to 4 by a reviewer working from the programme's own published materials.

    3
    Standards, Accuracy & Content Scope

    Is the content accurate, at the right level, and does it cover what it claims?

    3
    Focus, Coherence & Cognitive Rigor

    Does it build in a sensible order and make a student actually think?

    3
    Research-Consistent Instructional Design

    Is it taught in a way the research supports, with honest claims?

    3
    Assessment, Feedback & Demonstrable Mastery

    Can you actually see what your child learned, not just what they finished?

    3
    Accountability & Feedback Loop

    Does a qualified adult read your child's work and respond to it?

    3
    Adult Usability & Implementation Support

    How much work is this for you, and does it help you do that work?

    3
    Differentiation, Access & Learner Fit

    Does it flex for a struggling learner, an advanced one, or a different kind of learner?

    3
    Practical Feasibility & Transparency

    What does it truly cost, in money and time, and will it work where you live?

    3
    Academic Demand & College Readiness

    Is this preparing a student for college, or just for a diploma?

    The practical details

    Grades
    Pre-K through grade 12 (ages 3-18). Sold as age-banded Levels, not grades: Pre-K, then A through J, plus two high-school-specific levels…
    Subjects
    History and Geography (Reading with History), Literature via Read-Alouds and Readers, Language Arts (grammar, mechanics, writing, spelling, vocabulary), Science with a weekly hands-on lab, Handwriting (Levels A-D). Math is offered as a choice of four third-party publishers. NOT covered: foreign language, formal high…
    How it runs
    Physical box of books plus printed Instructor's Guides in binders. Zero screen time is required for the core program; the vendor states "students spend their day reading engaging books, discussing questions with their parents, or working on hands-on projects"…
    Who teaches
    The parent, entirely. BookShark supplies no instructor of any kind. The Instructor's Guide scripts the day: what to read, which discussion questions to ask, what to mark on the map, which lab to run, and (in Language Arts) teacher scripts. The FAQ is explicit that "BookShark is a curriculum provider, so there is no…
    Who grades
    The parent. Answers to every discussion question, vocabulary term, and map point are printed in the Parent Guide; writing is scored by the parent against BookShark-supplied rubrics; high school research reports are evaluated by the parent against written guidance ("Note to Instructors: As you evaluate your students' presentation, consider the research that was done as well as the final product,"…
    What the parent does
    Required teacher, discussion leader, and grader, every day the program runs. At Levels Pre-K through H the parent reads aloud daily and runs the "To Discuss After You Read" questions. From Levels I and J up through the two high school levels the student reads independently from a separate Student Guide while the parent holds the Parent Guide with the answers, the source notes, and the evaluation instructions. In all…
    Credit and records
    None provided. BookShark is not a school and not accredited; the FAQ states accreditation applies to institutions and never to curriculum, that there is no enrollment process, and that BookShark does not monitor progress. No credits are awarded, no grades are issued, and no transcript is produced. High school families are told to check with their local school district or a…
    Cost
    Published and itemized. Pre-K All-Subject Package $309.43 (retail $386.79). Levels A through J All-Subject Packages run roughly $863 to $1,322 (retail $1,082 to $1,653); examples: Level A $883.92 (retail $1,104.90), Level D $960.86 (retail $1,201.07), Level D Advanced $1,057.57 (retail $1,321.96), Level F $1,013.34 (retail $1,266.67) (https://www.bookshark.com/all-subject-packages). High School World History…
    Alaska notes
    Better disclosed than most print vendors, but still a real burden. Alaska, Hawaii, APO/FPO and US Territory orders of $75 or more may qualify for FREE Media Mail, but only if every item in the order qualifies. BookShark names the exclusions explicitly: science supply kits and components, microscopes, the markable map, art supplies, puzzles, math kits and manipulatives,…

    Strengths

    • Total pre-purchase transparency. A free 3-week sample of every single Instructor's Guide and a free scope-and-sequence for every level in every subject, downloadable without an email gate. A family…
    • The adult loop is physically in the box. Printed answers to every discussion question, map answer keys, teaching scripts, point-based and four-band writing rubrics with stated objectives, and…
    • High school work is intellectually real, not credit-farming. Full classic texts with literary analysis instruction, weekly primary source documents with source-critical prompts, roughly twenty…

    Weaknesses

    • Zero external validation of any kind, combined with claims that lean on it anyway. Not accredited, no state standards alignment ('we do not specifically follow any state standards'), no AP, no dual…
    • The entire accountability structure rests on one unverified adult with no checkpoint anywhere. BookShark states it does not monitor progress. If the parent stops asking the discussion questions and…
    • Workload disclosure is misleading by omission. The FAQ answers the parent-preparation question with 'Very little,' and no hours-per-day figure appears anywhere on the curriculum pages. That describes…
    Good fitA family with a parent who genuinely wants to teach and has the hours to do it: reading aloud daily, leading discussion, and marking writing against a rubric. It suits strong or eager readers, households combining two or three children within a 3-year age band into one history level, families who want a faith-neutral…
    Poor fitA family that needs an adult other than the parent in the loop: single-parent or two-working-parent households, a parent who is unwell or overextended, or any situation where nobody has two-plus hours a day to teach. Also a poor fit for a high schooler who needs validated college-prep credentials (AP, dual enrollment,…

    Reviewed from the programme's own published materials. Pricing and features change without notice, so confirm details with the publisher before buying. How FrostBoard rates curriculum